Author Topic: Scanner Performance still poor overall [update]  (Read 3320 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

September 18, 2009, 02:25:39 pm
Read 3320 times

cleanmx

  • Special Members
  • Hero Member

  • Offline
  • *

  • 3405
    • Spam-Filter Anti-Spam Virenschutz - CLEAN MX Managed Anti-Spam Service ist die Lösung für Ihr Spam-Problem
Hi

Out of 12.838 incidents here the scanner performance

not detected   percent   scanner
6466   49,63389936   GData
6706   47,76444929   Avast
7053   45,06153606   McAfee_GW_Edition
7073   44,90574856   AntiVir
8716   32,10780495   Ikarus
8796   31,48465493   a_squared
8884   30,7991899   F_Prot
9664   24,72347718   McAfee_Artemis
9901   22,87739523   McAfee
10406   18,94376071   Authentium
10498   18,22713818   BitDefender
10533   17,95451005   Kaspersky
10547   17,84545879   Sophos
10572   17,65072441   F_Secure
10842   15,54759308   AVG
11009   14,24676741   Microsoft
11325   11,78532482   ClamAV
11341   11,66069481   NOD32
11412   11,10764917   VirusBuster
11420   11,04533416   VBA32
11681   9,012307213   Comodo
11739   8,560523446   Symantec
11786   8,194422807   Fortinet
11844   7,74263904   DrWeb
11883   7,438853404   PCTools
11921   7,142857143   CAT_QuickHeal
11945   6,955912136   AhnLab_V3
11946   6,948122761   Panda
11958   6,854650257   Norman
11986   6,636547749   TrendMicro
12050   6,13802773   eTrust_Vet
12069   5,9900296   Sunbelt
12075   5,943293348   eSafe
12125   5,553824583   Prevx
12156   5,312353949   nProtect
12185   5,086462066   Rising
12233   4,712572052   Jiangmin
12241   4,650257049   Antiy_AVL
12427   3,201433245   TheHacker
12446   3,053435115   K7AntiVirus
12503   2,609440723   ViRobot


this ranking has been calculated base on this md5 consolidation database:
http://support.clean-mx.de/clean-mx/md5.php?sort=id%20desc

Update: 21.Sep.2009 md5 table now calclates these rankings on the fly

scanner   performance
ViRobot   2.76 %
K7AntiVirus   3.28 %
TheHacker   3.31 %
Antiy_AVL   4.81 %
Jiangmin   5.06 %
Rising   5.23 %
nProtect   5.5 %
Prevx   6.05 %
Sunbelt   6.34 %
eTrust_Vet   6.35 %
eSafe   6.85 %
TrendMicro   6.97 %
AhnLab_V3   7.04 %
Norman   7.26 %
Panda   7.4 %
CAT_QuickHeal   7.49 %
PCTools   7.61 %
DrWeb   8.09 %
Fortinet   8.43 %
Symantec   9.07 %
Comodo   9.13 %
VirusBuster   11.34 %
VBA32   11.48 %
NOD32   12.18 %
ClamAV   12.34 %
Microsoft   14.86 %
AVG   16.75 %
Sophos   18.24 %
Kaspersky   18.78 %
F_Secure   18.84 %
Authentium   19.95 %
BitDefender   20.39 %
McAfee   24.53 %
McAfee_Artemis   26.44 %
F_Prot   32.05 %
a_squared   32.81 %
Ikarus   33.37 %
AntiVir   45.91 %
McAfee_GW_Edition   47.24 %
Avast   48.76 %
GData   50.68 %


-- gerhard

September 18, 2009, 02:41:31 pm
Reply #1

Serg

  • Special Members
  • Sr. Member

  • Offline
  • *

  • 132
R u sharing samples with av vendors?

September 18, 2009, 02:47:06 pm
Reply #2

cleanmx

  • Special Members
  • Hero Member

  • Offline
  • *

  • 3405
    • Spam-Filter Anti-Spam Virenschutz - CLEAN MX Managed Anti-Spam Service ist die Lösung für Ihr Spam-Problem
no sharing, neither kaspersky, avira nor trendmicro are giving data to us.

--gerhard


September 18, 2009, 03:28:15 pm
Reply #3

SysAdMini

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member

  • Offline
  • *****

  • 3335
Interesting statistics. Ranking matches my experiences with some vendors. ;)

How have you done it ? Analysis of Virustotal reports ?
Ruining the bad guy's day

September 18, 2009, 03:30:46 pm
Reply #4

cleanmx

  • Special Members
  • Hero Member

  • Offline
  • *

  • 3405
    • Spam-Filter Anti-Spam Virenschutz - CLEAN MX Managed Anti-Spam Service ist die Lösung für Ihr Spam-Problem
yep, vt is now in my md5 db

-- gerhard